|
10
min read

Introduction: Why transparency in recruiting matters
Many candidates believe that hiring processes are objective, transparent and fair.
Reality often looks different.
After more than 25 years in IT sales and 19 years in executive search, I can tell you one thing:
Hiring is not a purely rational process.
It is not only about performance or your CV. It is about perception, risk assessment, internal politics and sometimes plain coincidence.
This article shows you what really happens behind the scenes, and how you can understand the game and use it to your advantage as a candidate or leader in the DACH market.
1. Sometimes you are only the benchmark, not the real candidate
It happens more often than most people think. You are invited, you go through several interviews, and at the end you hear:
“We have decided internally.”
The truth: you were never really in the race.
You were the benchmark, the comparison candidate used to measure an internal favorite.
Companies do this to back up a decision or to keep the process formally correct.
It is common practice at large US vendors and at big corporations in Germany.
My advice:
Even if the process feels strange, deliver anyway.
I have seen countless cases where the “benchmark” ended up getting the job because the original favorite dropped out.
2. Second place wins more often than you think
A rejection does not always mean the end.
Many runners-up receive an offer weeks later, because someone else declines or the budget shifts.
An example from my own practice:
An experienced Account Executive from Munich was turned down after three rounds.
Four weeks later the client called: “Our favorite has declined. Is Jan’s candidate still available?”
He was, and he got the job with a better package.
Takeaway:
Stay professional and respectful, even after a rejection.
Hiring managers remember candidates who handle it with composure.
3. Too much eagerness looks needy, not motivated
Many candidates believe that coming across as especially committed will impress.
In reality, the opposite can happen.
Following up too often, applying obvious pressure or showing exaggerated enthusiasm comes across as insecure, especially in the German market, where professionalism is often equated with calm and self-assurance.
My tip:
Be interested, but not needy.
Stay in touch, but give them space.
Hiring managers sense very quickly whether someone acts out of conviction or out of pressure.
4. “Cultural fit” is often just another word for bias
The term “cultural fit” sounds positive, but it is often misunderstood or used as cover.
In many companies it really means: “Fits in with us because he is like us.”
That leads to sameness instead of diversity.
I see this especially in tech sales:
Companies look for candidates who “fit the team” and often overlook the ones who could bring genuinely new perspectives.
As a trusted advisor, my view is clear:
A team needs differences to be strong.
If you only ever hire people like yourself, you block innovation.
5. The decision is often made in the first five minutes
Most hiring managers are not even aware of it, but they make their decision almost immediately.
This is called confirmation bias:
The first impression decides, and the rest of the conversation only serves to confirm it.
That is why I tell my candidates:
The first interview is not a knowledge test. It is a perception test.
Speak calmly and clearly, with real presence.
Behave as if you were already part of the team, but without arrogance.
6. “Overqualified” is rarely a compliment
When you hear “We thought you were great, but you are overqualified”,
it often means: “You are too expensive, too experienced or too strong for our structure.”
I have had cases where a top candidate was turned down because the hiring manager was afraid of being outshone.
That has nothing to do with you. It has to do with dynamics and insecurity on the company side.
My advice:
Feel free to ask: “What exactly do you mean by overqualified?”
That way you can find out whether the company really is the right fit for you.
Conclusion: The truth lies between the lines
Recruiting is never purely objective. It is human, political and emotional.
But if you understand the system, you lose less energy to frustration and can act more strategically.
My conclusion as a headhunter:
Learn to read between the lines.
Stay professional, even when a process feels unfair.
Focus on companies that show real decision quality, not just buzzwords like “cultural fit”.
Because in the end, it is not about getting every job.
It is about getting the right one.
Subscribe To My Newsletter
Get the latest insights delivered directly to your inbox!

