|
8
min read

When you have a good job, your phone rings. Headhunters message you on LinkedIn, invite you for a conversation and tell you about interesting roles. The moment you actually need a new job, it goes quiet. Same CV, same track record, a completely different response.
So why do employers prefer employed candidates? I’m Jan Nordh, founder of Nordh Executive Search. For 19 years I’ve placed senior sales and executive roles in cybersecurity, enterprise software, AI infrastructure and defense across DACH and the Nordics. Before that I spent 25 years in enterprise sales myself, from account executive to country manager, and helped build the European business of several US technology vendors. I’m also one of the people who make those calls to happily employed professionals. Here is what is really going on, and what you can do about it if you are currently on the quiet side.
What does commission breath have to do with your job search?
Anyone who has carried a quota knows two very different situations.
In the first, it’s the last week of the quarter. You’re at sixty percent of your number and there is exactly one deal left in the pipeline that can still close. On the customer call you discount faster, you say yes to requirements you would normally question, and you stop qualifying and start convincing. In sales this is called commission breath: the customer can sense that you need the deal. Surprisingly often, they then don’t buy at all, or only on their terms.
In the second, you have three times pipeline coverage and the quarter is going well. You ask about budget, the decision process and the real problem. If a deal doesn’t fit, you let it go. That calm is exactly what makes you credible.
Same salesperson, same product. The difference is the pipeline. A job search follows the same logic, and that is the core of what I call the pipeline test: does this candidate interview like someone with options, or like someone with one deal left?
Why do employers prefer employed candidates?
Part of the answer is commercial and fairly simple. My clients pay me to find people who are not applying. Someone who is succeeding in a role proves every day that they deliver. To a cautious employer, that feels like less risk.
There is also an old rule from every market: what is hard to get looks more valuable. A person who is not on the market gets more attention because they are harder to reach.
None of this says anything about ability. Many very good people are searching right now, often after a restructuring or an acquisition that had nothing to do with their performance. I know that feeling personally. Twice in my career I had to leave a company, and both times it had nothing to do with my numbers. If you want the hiring side of this in more detail, I wrote about why good salespeople need to become the safe choice.
How does pressure change the way you come across in an interview?
The employer’s perception is only half the story. The half that interests me more is what the pressure does to the candidate.
When I call a satisfied account executive, they run the conversation. They ask why the role is open, what happened to the predecessor, how much of the territory is existing business and how many people on the team hit quota last year. If they don’t like the answers, they politely decline. I have to convince them.
Now take the same person six months after a restructuring. The rejections have piled up and the savings are shrinking. Finally there is a first interview on a Teams call, for a role that really fits. The inner voice says: I can’t mess this up.
And then the last week of the quarter repeats itself:
You over-explain.
You agree to things you would normally challenge.
You forget that you are evaluating them too.
Hiring managers in enterprise sales watch for exactly this. Their silent question is simple: if this person gives in to me this easily, what will they do in a price negotiation with a corporate procurement team?
What is the difference between a pressured answer and a confident one?
Take the most common question in any first interview: why do you want to join us?
The pressured answer sounds like this: “I’ve followed your company for a long time, I think the product is great, I’m very flexible and happy to take any territory.” Nothing is wrong with it, but the hiring manager has learned nothing new. The message underneath is: please pick me.
The confident answer sounds like this: “You’re growing fast in the mid-market, and that’s exactly where I’ve been winning new logos over the last few years, with sales cycles of six to nine months. That’s what caught my attention. I’d like to understand what hasn’t worked in this territory so far, and what you want to achieve in the first twelve months.”
Both candidates want the job. One asks for approval, the other runs a discovery call. You don’t need a current job or a second offer to give the second answer. I’ve written a full guide on running an interview like a discovery call if you want the question list.
One warning: don’t play hard to get, and don’t pretend you have three other offers. Experienced hiring managers see through that as fast as a buyer sees through a salesperson’s bluff. You are allowed to want the job. Just don’t let the wanting run the conversation.
What happens when a candidate stops nodding?
Here is a pattern I see again and again, kept deliberately general. An enterprise account executive in cybersecurity, well above plan for years. After an acquisition, his whole unit is cut. He searches for months, gets first interviews and then nothing.
Across different companies the feedback says roughly the same thing: likeable, experienced, but we couldn’t really get a read on him. Going through his last interview made it clear why. The hiring manager had named a very ambitious first year number for a new territory, and he simply nodded. When a salesperson accepts a number like that without a single question, a sales leader wonders whether he did the math at all.
So I asked him to tell me about his best deal. Suddenly a different person was talking: how he worked his way up to the board over several months and won the deal against a major competitor. Calm, specific, with conviction. That is how he needed to sound in the interview.
There is research that fits this. In a 2013 study titled “Power Gets the Job”, applicants were asked before a selection interview to recall a situation in which they had influence, while a comparison group recalled a situation in which they felt powerless. The evaluators knew nothing about this and still rated the first group higher, partly because they came across as more persuasive. It was a lab experiment, not a guarantee. It does show that how you feel before the call is visible to the other side.
In his next interview another ambitious number came up. This time he said: “With a nine month sales cycle, that’s a stretch for year one. Here is how I would approach the territory, and here is what I’d need from you.” The hiring manager’s reaction: finally someone who does the math. He made it to the next round.
How do you interview from strength when you’re unemployed?
1. Change the goal of the conversation
Don’t walk in thinking you have to get this job. Walk in asking whether you can win here. Prepare questions the way you would for discovery: Why is the role open? What happened to your predecessor? How many people on the team hit quota? How will success be measured after six months?
2. Spend five minutes on your best deal before every interview
Write down what the challenge was, what you personally did and what came out of it. You are not putting on an act. You are recalling what you can actually do, and it changes how you sound.
3. Build pipeline
If you have only one interview in your calendar, you turn it into the last week of the quarter. Talk to several companies in parallel, and stay in touch with hiring managers and headhunters in your segment before roles are advertised. With three conversations running, not everything depends on one. My article on running parallel job processes covers how to manage the timing.
Why should you build pipeline while you still have a job?
This part is for everyone who has a good job right now. You don’t build pipeline in the last week of the quarter. Stay visible, keep your network warm and take the call even when you’re not looking. Restructurings rarely announce themselves. If your network has gone cold, here is how to reactivate it without sounding desperate.
Whether a company chooses you is out of your control. How well prepared you are, which questions you ask and how clearly you state your value is yours. Run your next interview the way you sell when your quarter is going well. The person across the table will notice the difference, even if they can’t put a name to it.
FAQ
Do employers really prefer employed candidates?
Often, yes. A candidate who is succeeding in a role looks like lower risk, and people who are hard to reach attract more attention. That preference is about perceived risk, not ability, and a well prepared unemployed candidate can offset much of it in the interview.
How should I explain being unemployed in an interview?
Say it plainly and briefly, for example that your unit was cut after an acquisition. Then move the conversation to the hiring manager’s territory and goals. A calm, factual answer followed by good questions signals far more confidence than a long justification.
How can I avoid sounding desperate in a job interview?
Prepare like a seller with a full pipeline. Have several conversations running, recall your best deal before each call and treat the interview as a discovery call where you are also evaluating the role.
If you work in cybersecurity, enterprise software or AI in DACH or the Nordics and want to talk about your positioning, reach out to me on LinkedIn or via nordh.de. You can also listen to the full episode in English or German: search for the Nordh Executive Search Podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
Subscribe To My Newsletter
Get the latest insights delivered directly to your inbox!

